Pomelo pulp and extract characteristics
The three pomelo cultivars, Kao Yai (white), Thong Dee (pink) and Siam Ruby (red), exhibited distinct differences in pulp morphology, color and texture, which were evident both visually and in sensory perception (Fig 1). Kao Yai fruits contained pale-white pulps with a relatively firm texture, while Thong Dee had pinkish pulps with moderate juiciness and Siam Ruby showed an intense red pulp color with a softer, juicier texture. These visual differences translated into distinct juice appearances: Kao Yai extracts were yellowish-white and slightly opaque, Thong Dee extracts appeared pinkish-white with higher turbidity due to suspended fibers and Siam Ruby extracts displayed an attractive pink coloration (Fig 2). The observed coloration corresponded well with the natural pulp pigments and confirmed findings from panelists, who consistently rated the extracts according to their visual appeal (Table 1).
Panelists also noted variations in aroma and taste. All extracts exhibited citrus aromatic notes characteristic of pomelo, but differences emerged in sweetness and sourness. Siam Ruby extracts were generally perceived as sweeter, while Kao Yai and Thong Dee extracts were described as more sour-sweet. This finding is consistent with earlier reports linking pulp pigmentation to perceived flavor intensity in citrus fruits
(Anmol et al., 2021; Balmori et al., 2023). In particular, the strong red pigmentation of Siam Ruby likely indicates the presence of anthocyanins or other flavonoid derivatives, which may influence both sensory appeal and nutritional value. These initial sensory assessments suggested that cultivar-specific pulp coloration and composition play a major role in consumer perception.
Instrumental color and physical properties
Instrumental color measurements further confirmed the sensory observations (Table 2). Kao Yai and Thong Dee extracts displayed similar lightness (L* values ~36), whereas Siam Ruby had significantly lower lightness (L* = 28.04±0.28) due to its strong red pigmentation, reflected in the highest a* value (7.91±0.02). Conversely, Kao Yai showed the lowest a* value (2.3±0.03) and the highest b* value (6.84±0.09), corresponding to a green-to-yellow hue. Such cultivar-dependent color parameters are consistent with pigment variability reported in other pomelo varieties
(Yin et al., 2022).
In terms of physicochemical properties, Siam Ruby extracts exhibited the highest pH (4.01±0.3), suggesting a lower acidity and aligning with its sweeter sensory profile. In contrast, Kao Yai extracts had the highest soluble solids (°Brix = 12.75), indicating higher sugar content despite being perceived as sourer. This highlights an interesting divergence between instrumental and sensory data: perceived sourness may be influenced not only by sugar content but also by the balance of organic acids and volatile compounds, as previously observed in citrus fruits (
Sarker and Oba, 2019).
Viscosity analyses revealed that Thong Dee extracts had the highest viscosity (25.50 cP) and torque values, likely due to the presence of higher amounts of suspended fibers and pectin. This finding supports the sensory observation of greater turbidity and less desirable mouthfeel in Thong Dee juices. The presence of pectin-rich suspensions may be nutritionally beneficial, particularly in weight management contexts, but less appealing in terms of consumer preference for fresh juices. Previous studies have also highlighted the role of insoluble fiber in reducing the acceptability of fresh juice products, even though such fibers are desirable in functional beverages (
Noor and Noranizan, 2018;
Nishad et al., 2018).
Thus, instrumental data aligned with sensory evaluation: Siam Ruby was visually attractive and moderately sweet, Kao Yai combined higher °Brix with strong sour-sweet balance and Thong Dee exhibited high fiber-induced turbidity but lower consumer appeal as a fresh beverage.
Sensory evaluation and consumer preference
Table 3 summarizes the sensory evaluation results. Siam Ruby extracts scored highest for color attractiveness (8.4/9), which is not surprising given its intense red pigmentation. Kao Yai achieved the highest scores for flavor (8.1/9), reflecting consumer appreciation for its balanced sour-sweet taste. Thong Dee consistently received lower scores across most attributes, particularly for texture (5.9/9), due to its fibrous and viscous nature.
Overall liking scores (7.42 for Kao Yai, 7.45 for Siam Ruby and 7.00 for Thong Dee) suggest that all cultivars were moderately liked. However, consumer preference diverged by attribute: Siam Ruby was most visually appealing and suitable as a premium fresh juice, whereas Kao Yai was more versatile, being both a refreshing beverage and a potential ingredient for desserts and mixed drinks. Thong Dee, while less appealing for direct consumption, holds potential for functional beverages aimed at health-conscious consumers, especially given its fiber content. Similar trends have been reported in citrus product development, where consumer acceptance is influenced not only by sweetness but also by visual appeal and texture
(Gupta et al., 2021).
Phytochemical content and antioxidant properties
The three pomelo cultivars differed significantly in their phytochemical composition (Table 4). Thong Dee extracts contained the highest total phenolic content (TPC = 45.74±8.12 mg GAE/100 ml) and tannin content (TC = 4.52±0.28 mg TAE/100 ml), suggesting greater phenolic-derived antioxidant potential. Siam Ruby extracts, on the other hand, showed the highest total flavonoid content (TFC = 35.06±3.87 mg RE/100 ml). Kao Yai extracts exhibited comparatively lower phytochemical levels across most categories, though their values remained within ranges reported for other white-pulp pomelo cultivars
(Abirami et al., 2014).
Despite these variations in phytochemical content, antioxidant activity measured by DPPH scavenging capacity did not differ significantly among the three cultivars (range: 78.54-83.25 mg TE/100 ml and 65.06-70.31 mg AE/100 ml).This finding suggests that while individual phytochemical components vary by cultivar, their combined antioxidant effects may reach a similar threshold. This observation supports previous reports of inconsistent correlations between phenolic content and antioxidant capacity in citrus species
(Pichaiyongvongdee et al., 2014).
Interestingly, the higher TFC in Siam Ruby could be attributed to its red pigmentation, potentially from anthocyanins and related flavonoids. These compounds contribute not only to visual appeal but also to potential health benefits. However, their presence did not translate into significantly higher antioxidant activity in vitro, reinforcing the idea that antioxidant bioactivity depends on complex interactions among multiple phytochemicals rather than the concentration of individual groups.
Our findings echo but also expand upon earlier literature.
Abirami et al. (2013, 2014) compared white and pink pomelo varieties and reported differences in phytochemical composition, with pink varieties generally showing higher phenolic contents. Our study confirms this trend but adds a new dimension by including a red cultivar (Siam Ruby), which demonstrated higher flavonoid levels. Similarly,
Chia and Chong (2013) highlighted that pomelo flavor profiles are strongly linked to pulp pigmentation, a relationship also evident in our sensory evaluations.
However, while previous studies often reported stronger antioxidant activities in pigmented cultivars, our results challenge this assumption by showing comparable antioxidant activity across all three cultivars. This discrepancy may be due to methodological differences or to the balancing effects of other compounds, such as ascorbic acid, that contribute to antioxidant capacity but are not directly linked to pulp coloration.
The higher viscosity and turbidity of Thong Dee juice align with findings from
Noor and Noranizan (2018), who reported that higher fiber and pectin content can reduce juice clarity and consumer acceptability. Nevertheless, as
Chen et al., (2023) emphasized, such fiber-rich beverages may have added value as functional or weight-management drinks, offering opportunities for targeted product development.
Practical implications and potential applications
From a product development perspective, Siam Ruby extracts, with their striking color and sweet profile, appear most suitable for premium fresh juice markets targeting consumers who prioritize visual appeal and mild sweetness. Kao Yai extracts, balancing higher °Brix with a refreshing sourness, could serve both as a standalone beverage and as a flavor enhancer in desserts and cocktails. Thong Dee extracts, while less desirable for fresh juice consumption due to fibrous texture, could be leveraged in functional beverages, potentially marketed for digestive health or dietary fiber intake.
Nutritionally, the phytochemical diversity among cultivars underscores the importance of considering varietal differences in designing pomelo-based products. While no single cultivar outperformed others across all parameters, each exhibited unique strengths-Siam Ruby in flavonoids, Thong Dee in phenolics and tannins and Kao Yai in sugar content. Such diversity provides opportunities for cultivar-specific marketing and tailored health claims.
Overall, the study demonstrates that pomelo pulp color is strongly associated with sensory attributes and phytochemical composition, though not necessarily with in vitro antioxidant capacity. These findings contribute to ongoing debates in citrus research, where correlations between pulp pigmentation, phytochemical levels and bioactivity remain complex and cultivar-dependent. By integrating sensory evaluation, physicochemical analysis and phytochemical profiling, our results highlight the unique strengths and limitations of each pomelo cultivar, offering practical guidance for both consumers and food product developers.