Standardization of protocol for salinity stress evaluation
The top-of-paper method was found superior to the between-paper method for evaluating seed quality parameters under varied salinity stress levels (0 to 9 dS/m), due to several advantages,including ease of handling, precise application of salt solutions at required concentrations and practical in execution. Among the different protocols tested for the top-of-paper method, the addition of 2.5ml NaCl solution every alternate day was proved to be most effective, maintaining adequate moisture without water stagnation during germination testing.
Analysis of variance for seedling quality parameters
The statistical analysis (ANOVA) revealed that treatment, accession and their interaction exerted highly significant effects (p<0.001) on all measured traits, including germination percentage, seedling length, fresh and dry weight (Table 2). These results underscore the strong influence of salt stress on seedling performance.The significant accession × treatment interaction further indicates that responses to salinity vary widely among accessions, reflecting a complex genetic basis for salt tolerance and emphasizing the role of both genetic background and environmental conditions for stress responses.
Germination percentage declined progressively with increasing salinity across all genotype groups (Fig 1A-1D). At 0 dS/m (control), black-seeded accessions recorded a mean germination of 75.51%, which declined to 67.81% at 3 dS/m, 52.77% at 6 dS/m and 36.46% at 9 dS/m. In contrast, yellow-seeded accessions recorded markedly lower germination values of 32.32%, 27.11%, 15.06% and 7.23% at 0, 3, 6 and 9 dS/m, respectively confirming that genotypes with yellow seed coat color were poor storers compared to black-seeded genotypes. For brown-seeded accessions, germination percentages were 68.33%, 56.66%, 38.33% and 23.33% at 0, 3, 6 and 9 dS/m, respectively. Similarly, for released varieties, values were 91.66%, 86.66%, 66.66% and 45.00% at corresponding salinity levels. Variation in germination percentage among genotypes may be attributed to differences in genetic makeup, metabolic activity and enzyme regulation
(Bojovic et al., 2010; Kondetti et al., 2012 and
Kandil et al., 2016).
A similar trend was observed for seedling length, fresh weight and dry weight, all of which decreased linearly with increasing salinity from 0 to 9 dS/m. This reduction may be attributed due to the osmotic stress limiting water uptake, restricted elongation and reduced enzyme activity involved in reserve mobilization from seeds to seedlings
(Kandil et al., 2012; Kondetti et al., 2012; Ayed et al., 2014 and
Tesfaye et al., 2014). Interestingly, few genotypes recorded highest germination percentage, seedling length and shoot and root dry weights at 3 dS/m, as low concentrations of NaCl may act as a nutrient, improving water uptake, promoting elongation, enhancing ion uptake, or facilitating better reserve mobilization under mild stress (
Essa, 2002;
Tamura and Chen, 2009 and
Gogile et al., 2013). Both Seedling Vigour Index-I (SVI-I) and Seedling Vigour Index-II (SVI-II) followed the same declining trend with increasing salinity across all genotypic groups. The variation in vigour indices among soybean genotypes reflected differential genotypic responses to salinity stress, with the lowest values of SVI-I and SVI-II recorded at the highest salinity level (9 dS/m).
Formulation of screening criteria for selection of tolerant and susceptible genotypes
Earlier studies have reported that seedling dry weight, which is the ultimate result of all physiological and biochemical activities in plant, is markedly reduced under high salt concentrations
(Akbarimoghaddam et al., 2011 and
Rumena, 2006). Physiological and seed quality parameters, along with their relationship to salt tolerant indices, have been proved as an applicable tool for selecting salt-tolerant genotypes
(Kagan et al., 2010; Khatun et al., 2013 and
Putri et al., 2022). For black seeded genotypes, the present study revealed a progressive decline in the Salt Tolerance Index (STI) with increasing salinity (0–9 dS/m). At 6 dS/m, the highest STI value was 90.19% in accession no. 80, while the lowest was 36.43% in accession no. 71. At 9 dS/m, accession no. 3 recorded the highest STI (71.69%), whereas accession no. 9 recorded the lowest (23.81%) (Fig 2A). Similarly, for yellow and brown seeded accessions, the STI averaged across all genotypic treatments decreased with an increase in the salinity level from 0 - 9 dS/m (Fig 2B and 2C). Among freshly harvested varieties, the highest STI value at 6 dS/m was 74.55% in variety Pusa 9712, while the lowest was 56.78% in SL 958. At 9 dS/m, Pusa 9712 again recorded the highest value (48.60%), whereas SL 958 had the lowest (28.50%) (Fig 2D).
Hence, based on the significant correlation of STI with several seed quality traits, genotypes were categorized into three groups: highly tolerant, moderately tolerant and highly susceptible. At salinity level of 6 dS/m, seed quality parameters (germination percentage, SVI-I, SVI-II and related traits) showed a positive correlation with STI for both black-seeded accessions and released varieties (Fig 3 and 4), whereas in yellow-seeded accessions, significant correlations were recorded at 3 dS/m (Fig 5).
In contrast, no significant correlations were detected for brown-seeded accessions at any salinity level; therefore, no categorization was made for this group. Further selection of tolerant and susceptible genotypes within the three groups: black-seeded accessions, yellow-seeded accessions and released varieties was carried out based on STI values at their respective salinity levels. In total, 20 genotypes were selected: 7 black-seeded, 7 yellow-seeded and all 6 released varieties. The selection was carried out at 3 dS/m for yellow-seeded accessions and at 6 dS/m for black-seeded accessions and released varieties. The calculated STI values were then arranged in increasing order and the genotypes were classified into three categories based on their ability to withstand salinity stress: highly tolerant, moderately tolerant and highly susceptible (Table 3 and Fig 6-8).
Correlation analysis of seed quality traits and salt tolerance index
Principal component analysis (PCA)
PCA (Fig 9) revealed that the first principal component explained 79% of the variance, largely driven by shoot length, root length, total seedling length and seedling dry weight. The second component explained an additional 8.8%. The clustering of these traits indicates their interrelated roles in salinity tolerance. Control treatments clustered separately from salinity treatments, reflecting baseline physiological responses. Similar clustering of stress-related traits has been reported in drought and salinity studies
(Lee et al., 2017; Gupta et al., 2020).These results suggest that PCA is effective in identifying key traits contributing to variation among genotypes under salinity stress. Traits that maintain their position closer to the control across increasing salinity levels might be more tolerant and hence valuable for breeding programs.
Multivariate selection using MGIDI
The Multi-Trait Genotype-Ideotype Distance Index (MGIDI) was employed to rank genotypes under control and salinity stress. By integrating multiple seedling traits, MGIDI enhanced selection efficiency and identified genotypes resilient under both optimal and stress conditions. A total of 156 genotypes were assessed for seed quality parameters under both normal and salt stress conditions for selecting the genotypes with high vigour. This approach identified eight superior soybean genotypes in each condition, highlighting varieties such as IC-81655, DS-76-35-4, Pusa -12, Pusa-9712, PS-1347, Himso-1681, DS-9703 and EC-14427 under control conditions and Pusa-9712, PS-1347, HIMSO-1574, Pusa-12, J-231, DS-76-37-2, EC-34141 and PS-1503 under salt stress (Fig 10). Genotypes near the cut-off threshold also displayed potential for tolerance and for further evaluation.