Indian Journal of Agricultural Research

  • Chief EditorT. Mohapatra

  • Print ISSN 0367-8245

  • Online ISSN 0976-058X

  • NAAS Rating 5.20

  • SJR 0.293

Frequency :
Bi-monthly (February, April, June, August, October and December)
Indexing Services :
BIOSIS Preview, ISI Citation Index, Biological Abstracts, Elsevier (Scopus and Embase), AGRICOLA, Google Scholar, CrossRef, CAB Abstracting Journals, Chemical Abstracts, Indian Science Abstracts, EBSCO Indexing Services, Index Copernicus

Evaluation the Efficiency of Newly Combined Herbicide Pyroxsulam and Galaxifen-methyl in Winter Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.)

A.S. Golubev1, Ali A.S. Al-Maliki2,*, V.I. Dolzhenko1, A.P. Savva3, T.V. Dolzhenko2,4
1All-Russian Institute of Plant Protection, Russia.
2Saint-Petersburg State Agrarian University, Russia.
3All-Russian Research Institute of Biological Plant Protection, Russia.
4LLC Innovation Center for Plant Protection, Saint-Petersburg, Russia.

Background: Globally, wheat production is essential for food security as it is an essential staple food crop for a huge population. However, there are different biotic and abiotic factors affected the productivity of wheat. One of the essential competitors of wheat crop are weeds. Wheat is infested by both annual and perennial dicotyledonous weeds. The main purpose of this study is to evaluate the efficiency of the new combined herbicide Tarzec WG based on pyroxsulam and galaxifen-methyl + safener cloquintocet-mexyl for protecting winter wheat from the weeds. 

Methods: The field experiment was conducted during 2019 and 2020. The experimental treatments consisted of Tarzec two application rates: 19 g/ha and 22 g/ha.Reference standards were applied, Pallas 45 (22 g/ha of pyroxsulam). 

Result: Results revealed that the greatest advantage of the combined herbicide Tarzec WG over the single-component agent Pallas 45 OD was attained through the inhibition degree against weeds in both the seasons of experiment. Unfortunately, these compelling advantages of combined agent over the single-component one was not identified with respect to Cerastiumnemorale, Avenafatua and Alopecurus myosuroides. Tarzec WG herbicide was not phytotoxic to the plants of the winter wheat. 

Winter wheat is a valuable cereal that is essential in cooking many foods that make up the diet of modern human. In Russia, one of the most favorable regions for cultivation of this crop in terms of soil and climatic conditions is Krasnodar Krai. Regardless of the farmers’ use of improved varieties and good agricultural practices, there is a large discrepancy between farmers’ yields and the potential yield of this crop. There are several factors responsible for the decrease in production per unit area in the wheat yield. Among these factors, weed infestation plays a critical role in determining the production of wheat.
Compared to other factors such as population density, crop variety and plant nutrition, losses caused by weeds estimate more loss (27%-38%) (Jaffar et al., 2023). According to Chauhan, (2020) globally, it is estimated that, the crop losses due to weeds are projected as 100 billion dollars.
It is impossible to achieve high yields of winter wheat even in regions favorable for its cultivation without taking protective measures against weeds (Fetyukhin and Baranov, 2019). The existing range of herbicides do not fully meet the demands of time. Most agents on the market protect crops from only one of the groups of weeds-cereals or dicotyledons, while the most common type of weed infestation in the fields is mixed (Luneva and Zakota, 2018).
Among the few primary materials capable of meeting such a challenge is pyroxsulam. This herbicide efficiently destroys such grass weeds as downy brome (Bromus tectorum L.), wild oat (Avena fatua L.) and ryegrass (Lolium temulentum L.) (El-Metwally and Gad, 2019). The herbicide is efficient against such dicotyledon weeds as flixweed (Descurainiasophia L.), blue mustard (Chorisporatenella (Pallas) DC.) and henbit (Lamium amplexicaule L.) (Reddy et al., 2013). Despite the high efficiency of pyroxsulam, three problems related to its use have been revealed in recent years.
First, some types of weeds were not too sensitive to pyroxsulam. Practice shows that pure pyroxsulam is not sufficient to efficiently control Redroot pigweed (Amaranthus retroflexus L) in winter wheat (Zargar et al., 2020).
Second, it was found that high rates of pyroxsulam application might have negative impacts on crop plants. Practice shows that application of 15 and 18 g a.i. ha-1 pyroxsulam did not cause visual injury above 10% in wheat. However, pyroxsulam may visual injury to wheat when applied at 21, 30, 36 and 42 g a.i. ha-1 (Zobiole et al., 2018).
Third, weeds started developing tolerance to the herbicide. Initially, pyroxsulam (ALS-inhibiting herbicides) was used to combat weed plants (such as Alopecurus ssp.), that developed tolerance to ACCase-inhibiting herbicides. However, in a while, weeds started developing tolerance to this herbicide as well (Huang et al., 2021). Over time, the number of tolerant weed species began to increase and this fact keeps being reported. Tolerant populations of Italian Ryegrass (Lolium perenne L. ssp. multiflorum (Lam.) Husnot) were found in North Carolina (Jones et al., 2021).
The problems demonstrated may be resolved by using tank mixtures of herbicides based on primary materials having different action modes (e.g., ALS-and ACCase inhibiting) (Petersen, 2018), or through presentation of combined agents. In this respect, special interest arises to agents based on new primary materials such as halauxifen-methyl which is one of the few herbicide molecules discovered in early 21st century (Epp et al., 2016).
Halauxifen-methyl is a new auxinic herbicide for broadleaf weed control for a wide range of crops: corn, soybean, grassland, pasture, woody landscape ornamentals (Krenchinski et al., 2019; McCauley and Young, 2019; Zimmer et al., 2019). Halauxifen-methyl applied alone controlled small and large horseweed (including Glyphosate-Resistant) [Conyza Canadensis (L.) Cronq.], common ragweed (Ambrosia artemisiifolia L.), henbit (Lamium amplexicaule L.), purple deadnettle (Lamium purpureum L.), yet it is less efficient against Polygonum (Polygonum persicaria L., P. pensylvanicum L., P. hydropiper L., P. orientale L., pigweed (Amaranthus retroflexus L.), common chickweed [Stellaria media (L.) Vill.] (Askew et al., 2021).
On cereals, it is mostly a component for combined agents. For instance, in Europe the first two premix herbicides containing halauxifen-methyl are Zypar (with florasulam) and Pixxaro (with fluroxypyr) (Dzikowski, et al., 2016).
The main objective of the research is to study the efficiency of the new Tarzec WG herbicide based on pyroxsulam and halauxifen-methyl on winter wheat plantings and evaluate its safety for crop plants.
The research was carried out on experimental field of All-Russian Institute of Plant Protection (VIZR) in Krasnodar Krai (45.0 N, 38.8 E) during the vegetation periods of 2018-2019 and 2019-2020. Soft winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) Kalym strain was cultivated on the experimental ground. The plant is short-growing. Weight of 1,000 grains is 33-44 g. The cultivar is mid-ripening.
The soil is chernozem (black soil), weakly-leached, extra-thick; with heavy-loamy particle-size distribution; with humus content in topsoil of 3.7%; pH=6.9. Seeding rate was 200 kg/ha. Previous crop was winter wheat. Soil treatment: disk harrowing, plowing to a depth of 22-25 cm, pre-seeding cultivation.
Weather conditions in 2019 were characterized by higher air humidity and large amount of precipitation, the latter being about 50% above normal. In the conditions of 2020, the amount of precipitation was 15% above normal. The temperature in both years of research was at the level of long-term annual average values (differences on average did not exceed 1-2°C). All this contributed, on the one hand, to the rapid development of winter wheat plants and, on the other hand, to the development of weeds.
The area of each plot was 25 m2. The plots were randomly allocated around the experimental field. Each option of the experiment was set to four repetitions. Table 1 illustrated the details of the agent under study, its reference standards and adjuvants.

Table 1: Details of products, common name and active ingredients.

Adjuvants have been used as their adding to herbicides, their efficacy is significantly increased (Sobiechet al., 2020). It is known that nonionic surfactant (isodecyl alcohol ethoxylate) is not the best adjuvant of pyroxsulam, therefore, we used Surfer (2-ethyl hexanol eo-po) (Hamoudaet al., 2021).
Treatment was carried out on vegetating winter-wheat plants (BBCH 30-32) using manual low-volume sprayer in accordance with the experimental design given in (Table 2). The flow rate of the process fluid was calculated based on 200 l/ha.Tarzec was applied at two application rates: 19 g/ha and 22 g/ha. An herbicide based on pure pyroxsulam-Pallas 45 (22 g/ha of pyroxsulam) was used as one of reference standards.

Table 2: Details of treatments and application rates.

In the untreated control, the exact number of weeds was counted prior to the experiment and during each evaluation of the efficiency. Efficiency was recorded visually 14, 28 and 56 days after treatment.
The yield of winter weed was gathered with Hege 125 harvester. The data obtained in the experiments were subjected to statistical processing by analysis of variance (ANOVA) method at a probability level of 95%.
Dicotyledonous and grass weeds
Before the treatment in 2019, weeds from two groups-dicotyledonous and grass weeds-were found on the experimental ground. The first group included the following species: catchweed bedstraw (Galium aparine L.; BBCH 25; 17 specimen/m2), corn poppy (Papaver rhoeas L.; BBCH 25; 12 specimen/m2), wood cerastium (Cerastium nemorale M. Bieb.; BBCH 51; 9 specimen/m2). The second group included: common wild oat (Avena fatua L.; BBCH 25; 18 specimen/m2) and black foxtail (Alopecurus myosuroides Huds; BBCH 27; 37 specimen/m2). In 2020, before the treatment, the species composition of weeds was similar, but their total number was less by 17% (77 specimen/m2).

Table 3 shows the weed density in control plot during the period of experiment.

Table 3: The weed density in control plot.

Efficiency of herbicides
A significant excess of the efficiency of the combined agent over the single-component one was noted by the effect on two types of weeds: Galium aparine and, specifically, on Papaver rhoeas.
Common poppy (Papaver rhoeas)
Pure pyroxsulam’s effect on Papaver rhoeas was the least: in the first year of research, the number of plants of this species decreased by 5.5-24.0% and in the second year, the reference standard Pallas 45 OD had no effect on them at all.
As is shown in Table (4) the use of Tarzec WG herbicide against Papaver rhoeas was significantly more efficient: in the first year of research. The efficiency of both application rates exceeded that of both reference standards (91.8-100%); in the second year, the efficiency of 0.075 kg ha-1 of Tarzec herbicide was equal to that of the reference standard and the efficiency of 0.09 kg ha-1 was the highest in the experiment (89.3-95.5%).

Table 4: Efficiency of herbicides against weed species, % to nontreated check (2019, 2020).

Cleavers (Galium aparine)
The use of Tarzec in both application rates in 2019 made it possible to destroy all plants of Galium aparine (100%) in 28 and 56 days after treatment (Table 4). The efficiency of reference standard Pallas 45 OD was credibly lower than this level. Reference standard Verdict WG was the least efficient in the experience (72.8-81.5%).
In 2020, the efficiency of 0.075 kg ha-1 of Tarzec herbicide exceeded that of the Pallas reference standard in 28 and 56 days after application and the efficiency of 0.09 kg ha-1 of the agent under study exceeded that of all other herbicide options during the entire observation period (Table 4).
Cerastium nemorale
With respect to Cerastium nemorale, the efficiency of pure pyroxsulam (93.8-100%) in the first year of research was equal to that of the combined agent in both application rates. All of these options credibly exceeded the performance of reference standard Verdikt WG.
In the second year, with records on days 14 and 28, the efficiency of 0.075 kg ha-1 of Tarzec herbicide exceed that of Pallas 45 OD reference standard and the efficiency of 0.09 kg ha-1 of Tarzec herbicide was the highest in the experiment during all observations (90.3-96.5%).
It is known that Corn poppy (Papaver rhoeas L.) having developed herbicide resistance to acetolactate synthase inhibitors, especially in Mediterranean countries and Great Britain (Stankiewicz-Kosyl et al., 2020). Therefore, obvious is the benefit of herbicides mixtures with halauxifen-methyl for the control of Papaver resistant to ALS herbicides (Group 2) as well as 2, 4-D (Sleugh et al., 2021). Concerning grass weeds, the use of combined agent in the first year of research had no significant advantage: pure-pyroxsulam efficiency against Avenafatua and Alopecurus myosuroides was at the level of the maximum combined-agent application rate. A lesser herbicide application rate was less efficient. Altogether, it corresponds with the available. Furthermore, Morderer et al., (2018) noticed that Mixing halauxifen-methyl with pyroxsulam and florasulam increases the effectiveness for controlling perennial dicotyledonous in wheat crops. Data that Halauxifen-methyl combination with pyroxsulam succeeded to control both broad and grassy weed without antagonistic effect between them (Morderer et al., 2018).
In the second year of the study, the combined agent had an advantage over the single-component one in both application rates. Identification of chromosomes in Triticum aestivum possessing genes that confer tolerance to halauxifen-methyl is currently under study (Obenland and Riechers, 2020) and the herbicides based on this primary material are produced with the safener cloquintocet-mexyl. Safeners associated to ALS inhibitors reduce the sensitivity grass weeds to their associated herbicides (Duhoux et al., 2017). Therefore, it is possible that the advantage of combined agent was caused by the lesser amount of safener cloquintocet-mexyl (0.02655 kg and 0.03186 kg per ha of Tarzec WG VS 0.045 kg/ha of Pallas 45 OD).
The use of Tarzec WG herbicide, as well as reference standards Pallas 45 OD and Verdikt WG had not negative effect on winter wheat Kalym strain plants. Spots, necroses or other symptoms of phytotoxicity were not found on herbicide-treated plots during the whole experimental period. The winter wheat plants, whether herbicide-treated or untreated-control, were developing simultaneously.
In the untreated control, the yield of winter wheat Kalym strain was 43.9 dt/ha (in 2019) and 46.2 dt/ha (in 2020). In all herbicide options, a significant increase in crop yield was noted: by 9.3-11.8% in 2019; by 8.7-10.4% in 2020 (Fig 1). Despite the stronger inhibition of some weed species in comparison with the reference standard in the options where herbicide Tarzec WG herbicide was applied, the yield of winter wheat in all herbicide options was at the same level.

Fig 1: Winter wheat yield after herbicides treatments (2019, 2020). The vertical bars represent LSD 0.05.

In general, it can be concluded that the application of the candidate herbicides are considered very Important effective treatments to control harmful weeds. These compelling advantages of combined agent over the single-component one was not identified with respect to Cerastium nemorale, Avena fatua and Alopecurus myosuroides. Being used, Tarzec WG herbicide was not phytotoxic to the plants of winter wheat Kalym strain. When the agent was applied additionally to the untreated control, from 4.5 dt/ha to 5.2 dt/ha of winter wheat grain was obtained.

  1. Askew, M.C., Cahoon, C.W.J., York, A.C., Flessner, M.L., Langston, D.B.J. and Ferebee, J.H. (2021). Comparison of 2, 4-D, dicamba and halauxifen-methyl alone or in combination with glyphosate for preplant weed control. Weed Technol. 35: 93-98.

  2. Chauhan, B.S. (2020). Grand challenges in weed management. Frontiers in Agronomy. 1(3): 1-4. 

  3. Duhoux, A., Pernin, F., Desserre, D. and Délye, C. (2017). Herbicide safeners decrease sensitivity to herbicides inhibiting acetolactate-synthase and likely activate non-target-site- based resistance pathways in the major grass weed lolium sp. (Rye-Grass). Frontiers in Plant Science. 8: 1310.

  4. Dzikowski, M., Becker, J., Larelle, D., Kamerichs, B. and Gast, R. (2016). ArylexTM active- new herbicide active and base for new cereals herbicides: Zypar™ and Pixxaro ™ EC to control wide range of broadleaf weeds in cereals in Europe. 27. Deutsche Arbeitsbesprechung uber Fragen der Unkrautbiologie und -bekampfung, 23.-25.02.2016 in Braunschweig. Julius-Kuhn-Archiv. 452: 297-304.

  5. El-Metwally, I.M. and Gad, N. (2019). Wheat productivity and water use efficiency responses to irrigation, cobalt and weed management. Italian Journal of Agrometeorology. 1: 13-24.

  6. Epp, J.B., Alexander, A.L., Balko, T.W., Buysse, A.M., Brewster, W.K., Bryan, K., Daeuble, J. F., Fields, S.C. et al. (2016). The discovery of Arylex™ active and Rinskor™ active: Two novel auxin herbicides. Bioorganic and Medicinal Chemistry. 24(3): 362-371.

  7. Fetyukhin, I.V. and Baranov, A.A. (2019). Integrated protection of winter wheat from weeds. Grain Economy of Russia. 1: 6-9. 

  8. Hamouda, S.S.A., El-Tawil, M.F., Marzouk, E.M.A. and Khalifa, H.M.S. (2021). Efficiency of certain herbicides and adjuvants combinations against weeds in wheat fields. Egyptian Academic Journal of Biological Sciences F. Toxicology and Pest Control. 13(1): 1-14.

  9. Huang, Z., Lu, X., Wei, S., Zhang, C., Jiang, C., Li, W., Saeed, M. and Huang H. (2021). The target-site based resistance mechanism of Alopecurus myosuroides Huds. to pyroxsulam. Crop Protection. 147: 105707.

  10. Jaffar, M.T., Zhang, J., Rehaman, S., Dar, A., Ayyub, M. and Zahir, A.Z. (2023). The trend towards suppressing most troublesome weeds for sustainable production of wheat. Food and Agriculture on Social, Economic and Environmental Linkages. March: 74-105.  

  11. Jones, E.A.L., Taylor, Z.R. and Everman, W.J. (2021). Distribution and Control of Herbicide-Resistant Italian Ryegrass [Lolium perenne L. ssp. multiflorum (Lam.) Husnot] in Winter Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) in North Carolina. Frontiers in Agronomy. 2: 1-8.

  12. Krenchinski, F.H., Pereira, V.G.C., Zobiole, L.H.S., Albrecht, A.J.P., Albrecht, L.P. and Peterson, M. (2019). Halauxifen- Methyl+Diclosulam: New option to control conyza spp. prior soybean sowing. Planta Daninha. 37: e019189000.

  13. Luneva, N.N., Zakota, T.Y. (2018). Weed species composition and quantitative parameters of weed infestation of winter wheat crops in the steppe zone of Krasnodar Territory. Plant Protection News. 1(95): 45-52.

  14. McCauley, C. and Young, B. (2019). Differential response of horseweed (Conyza canadensis) to halauxifen-methyl, 2, 4-D and dicamba. Weed Technology. 33(5): 673-679.

  15. Morderer, Y.Y., Sychuk, A.M., Rodzevych, Î.P., Pavlenko, V.V. and Sarbash, Î.M. (2018). Effectiveness of auxin-like herbicide halauxifen-methyl mixtures with other herbicides for canada thistle (Cirsium arvense) control in wheat crops. Plant Physiology and Genetics. 6: 508-516.

  16. Obenland, O.A. and Riechers, D.E. (2020). Identification of chromosomes in Triticum aestivum possessing genes that confer tolerance to the synthetic auxin herbicide halauxifen- methyl. Scientific Reports. 10: 8713(2020). 10.1038/s41598-020-65434-x.

  17. Petersen, J. (2018). Herbicide mixtures for control of herbicide resistant Apera spica-venti populations. 28. Deutsche Arbeitsbesprechung uber Fragen der Unkrautbiologie und-bekampfung, 27.02.-01.03.2018 in Braunschweig. Julius-Kuhn-Archiv. 458: 106-112.

  18. Reddy, S.S., Stahlman, P.W. and Geier, P.W. (2013). Downy Brome (Bromus tectorum L.) and Broadleaf Weed control in winter wheat with acetolactate synthase-inhibiting herbicides. Agronomy. 3: 340-348.

  19. Sleugh, B.B., Wright, T.R., Salas, M., Simpson, D.M., Schmitzer, P.R., Morell, M. and Saunders, D.W. (2021). Corteva Agriscience’s perspective and commitment to managing herbicide resistance. Pest Management Science. 77: 1572-1577.

  20. Sobiech, £., Grzanka, M., Skrzypczak, G., Idziak, R., W³odarczak, S. and Ochowiak, M. (2020). Effect of adjuvants and ph adjuster on the efficacy of sulcotrione herbicide. Agronomy. 10(4): 530.

  21. Stankiewicz-Kosyl, M., Synowiec, A., Haliniarz, M., Wenda-Piesik, A., Domaradzki, K., Parylak, D. et al. (2020). Herbicide resistance and management options of Papaver rhoeas L. and Centaurea cyanus L. in Europe: A Review. Agronomy. 10(6): 874.

  22. Zargar, M., Bayat, M. and Astarkhanova, T. (2020). Study of postemergence-directed herbicides for redroot pigweed (Amaranthus retroflexus L.) control in winter wheat in Southern Russia. Journal of Plant Protection Research. 60(1): 7-13.

  23. Zimmer, M., Young, B. and Johnson, W. (2019). Halauxifen-methyl preplant intervals and environmental conditions in soybean. Weed Technology. 33(5): 680-685.

  24. Zobiole, L.H.S., Gast, R., Masters, R.A., Pereira, G.R. and Rubin, R. (2018). Pyroxsulam: Sulfonamide herbicide for weed control in wheat in Brazil. Planta Daninha. 36: e018155253.

Editorial Board

View all (0)