The first trial showed no significant interaction between nursery media and stem cutting length on
Moringa seedling growth; however, both factors individually influenced development during the two-month nursery period.
Shoot length and first day of sprouting
Table 1 indicates that cutting length and nursery media significantly affected sprouting time and shoot length. Longer cuttings (60 cm) sprouted earlier (7.4 dap) and produced taller shoots (36.1 cm at 60 dap) than shorter cuttings (20 cm, 11.7 dap; 9.7 cm). This supports the idea that longer cuttings retain greater nutrient and hormone reserves
(Smith et al., 2019). Compost-enriched topsoil also produced taller shoots (33.5 cm) than plain topsoil (19.8 cm), emphasizing the role of organic matter in nutrient supply and moisture retention.
Shoot number and number of leaves
As shown in Table 2, both cutting length and media significantly affected shoot number. The 60 cm cuttings produced the most shoots (5.9), while compost-enriched topsoil also supported higher shoot numbers (4.5) than plain topsoil (3.4). These results align with theories of resource allocation, where larger propagules and nutrient-rich media enhance shoot proliferation.
Leaf number increased with cutting length (Table 2). The 60 cm cuttings produced the highest leaf count (35.3 leaves) and compost-enriched media supported more leaves (27.6) than topsoil (18.5). This highlights the importance of cutting size and media fertility in supporting greater photosynthetic area and biomass formation
(Smith et al., 2019; Perez and Santos, 2017).
Number and length of roots
Cutting length significantly affected root number and root length (Table 3). The 60 cm cuttings produced more roots (21.6) and greater root length, especially in compost-enriched media (7.9 cm), compared with topsoil (5.7 cm). Larger cuttings and fertile media enhance root system development, improving water and nutrient uptake.
Shoot fresh and dry weight and root fresh and dry weight
Shoot biomass was significantly influenced by cutting length and media (Table 4). Longer cuttings produced higher fresh (95.8 g) and dry weight (15.9 g) values and compost-enriched media further boosted biomass (87.6 g vs. 59.4 g). Nutrient-rich media support higher biomass accumulation
(Smith et al., 2019).
Root biomass followed the same trends, with longer cuttings and compost-amended media producing the highest fresh (7.86 g) and dry weights (1.61 g) (Table 4). This confirms the significance of cutting size and media fertility in root development.
Physiological interpretation of cutting responses
Table 1-4 collectively show superior seedling growth from 40 cm and 60 cm cuttings grown in compost-enriched topsoil. Larger cuttings contain more stored carbohydrates and more mature tissues, supporting rapid sprouting, bud break and rooting. This contrasts with
Leakey’s (1985) view that large cuttings from mature trees are harder to root, but maturity and stored reserves in this study favored regeneration. Leafless cuttings often rely on internal reserves (
Leakey, 1999) and longer cuttings provide higher carbohydrate stores necessary for bud activation and re-differentiation
(Hartmann et al., 2007). Prior studies in
Jatropha and
Azadirachta also confirm superior rooting from longer cuttings
(Santoso et al., 2008; Palanisamy and Kumar, 1997). Thus, longer cuttings promote faster shoot and root development through increased carbohydrate availability
(Hartmann et al., 2007; Leakey, 1999).
Although cutting length did not significantly affect the timing of first root emergence (9-11 dap), longer cuttings produced more and longer roots. This aligns with findings that cutting length affects root number across species (
Leakey, 1999;
Howard, 1996). Longer cuttings also exhibited greater root dry weight, indicating stronger root systems essential for shoot growth.
Shoot-root ratio and seedling percentage
As shown in Table 5, compost-amended media produced the highest seedling establishment (91.1%) and 40 cm cuttings produced the highest establishment among cutting lengths (86.2%). Although 60 cm cuttings generally produced more vigorous shoots and roots (Table 1-4), 40 cm cuttings showed a more balanced shoot-root ratio and higher establishment, which is advantageous for transplanting and for reducing the amount of cutting material removed from mother plants. A smaller shoot-root ratio increases seedling resilience during transplanting
(Siagian et al., 1994), as it enhances water and nutrient uptake relative to transpiration demand. Seedling success rates were much higher in 40 cm (86.2%) and 60 cm (72.1%) cuttings than in 20 cm cuttings (20.6%). Media effects were also clear, with compost media producing higher establishment than topsoil alone (79.5%), likely due to improved aeration, nutrient availability and microbial activity (
Dickens, 2011;
Peter-Onoh et al., 2014;
Kreshnadhi et al., 2021; Leakey, 1999).
Overall, high-quality
Moringa seedlings depend on cutting size and media fertility. Stands with strong biomass potential require vigorous seedlings (
Santoso and Jayaputra, 2023) and this study confirms that 60 cm cuttings are optimal, though 40 cm cuttings remain suitable for propagation (
Santoso and Parwata, 2020;
Hartmann et al., 2007). These results reinforce the value of vegetative propagation for
Moringa and support further research on economic feasibility and long-term field performance
(Smith et al., 2019).
The second experiment showed that seedlings selected from Trial 1 responded differently to plant spacing after transplanting in the field. As shown in Table 6, increasing plant density increased leaf number and shoot branch length but reduced branch number and branch width (p<0.05). These results are consistent with spacing optimization principles that balance competition and resource capture
(Smith et al., 2019).
Spacing significantly affected leaf and stem biomass (Table 7). Closer spacing (25 x 25 cm) produced higher plot-level fresh and dry weights, while wider spacing improved individual plant biomass. This pattern is consistent with biomass optimization across densities, where high densities improve total yield per area despite reduced individual plant size.
Leaf biomass increased with population density, with the highest values at 160,000 plants ha-1 (25 x 25 cm). Densities of 62,500 and 111,111 plants ha-1 produced similar but lower biomass. These findings align with
Goss (2012), who reported biomass increases with higher density. Leaf biomass, the key economic component of Moringa
(Ridwan et al., 2021), increased due to improved radiation capture and root distribution at high densities. The importance of moringa-based biostimulant and biomass-oriented management has also been noted in recent studies on crop productivity and foliage quality
(Truong et al., 2023).
Optimal spacing ensures maximum yield per land area, as supported by studies in other perennial and annual crops
(Salik et al., 2023; Khan and Rab, 2019). In this study, the densest spacing (160,000 plants ha
-1) produced the tallest plants and highest biomass. Similar responses were reported by
Santos et al., (2021), Abdullahi et al., (2013), Adegun et al., (2013) and
Ahmed et al., (2023) across various species.