Agricultural Science Digest

  • Chief EditorArvind kumar

  • Print ISSN 0253-150X

  • Online ISSN 0976-0547

  • NAAS Rating 4.75

  • SJR 0.156

Frequency :
Bi-monthly (February, April, June, August, October and December)
Indexing Services :
BIOSIS Preview, Biological Abstracts, Elsevier (Scopus and Embase), AGRICOLA, Google Scholar, CrossRef, CAB Abstracting Journals, Chemical Abstracts, Indian Science Abstracts, EBSCO Indexing Services, Index Copernicus
Agricultural Science Digest, volume 43 issue 1 (february 2023) : 87-91

The Release of Trichogrammatoidea armigera parasitoid for the Parasitization of Helicoverpa armigera Eggs in Maize

Jimmy Rimbing1,*, Frangky Rorong1, Dantje Tarore1
1Department of Plant Pests and Diseases, Faculty of Agriculture, Sam Ratulangi University, Manado-95115, Indonesia.
Cite article:- Rimbing Jimmy, Rorong Frangky, Tarore Dantje (2023). The Release of Trichogrammatoidea armigera parasitoid for the Parasitization of Helicoverpa armigera Eggs in Maize . Agricultural Science Digest. 43(1): 87-91. doi: 10.18805/ag.DF-466.
Background: Helicoverpa armigera (Hübner) is a common polyphagous pest on corn cob. H. armigera that is controllable through Trichogrammatoidea armigera (Nagaraja) parasitoid release. Successful inundated release of parasitoids depends on parasitization and parasitoid dispersal.

Methods: The experiment consisted of 2 parasitoid release plots and 1 no release plot. T. armigera parasitoid was released twice, at 45 DAP and 52 DAP (Day after planting) in the middle of the experimental plot. The dose of parasitoid released during the corn generative phase was 1000 individuals per 254 m2 (~ 40000/ha). Evaluation was carried out by collecting the eggs of H. armigera 3 days after release at radius 1, 3, 6 and 9 m in all cardinal directions from the release point.

Result: The release of parasitoids increased the eggs parasitization of H. armigera in 45 DAP tot he tune of 51.91% and 52 DAP was 38.57%. The wind direction did not affect the parasitoid movement which is active and almost uniform in all cardinal directions. Parasitoid movement was slightly similar in all distances and cardinal directions. The distribution of parasitoids reached 9 m from 40 release points ha-1 in colonies. T. armigera parasitoids were grouped hence, the monitoring in corn was carried out systematically.
The main problem in corn cultivation is controlling Helicoverpa armigera pest, a polyphagous that mainly attacks soybean, tomatoes and cotton. H. armigera larvae damages corn cobs and feeds internally thus makes it difficult to control using insecticides. However the moths of H. armigera lay eggs on cobs silk and amenable for egg parasitisation. Egg parasitoid Trichogrammatoidea armigera has been found effective in controlling this pest. The parasitoid is broadly found in corn plantations in North Sulawesi, naturally 13.1 to 18.6% parasitisation but  it has not been used as a controlling agent (Rimbing et al., 2013).

The systematic study in this region is not made by inundative release of this parasitoid to establish how much it will control the pest. How parasitoid T. armigera controls H. armigera should be examined to assess the inundation release of the parasitoid in controlling H. armigera. Parasitoids can control specific pests and suppress pest populations. Successful parasitoids release requires data on parasitization and parasitoid behavior.

In North Sulawesi, Major egg parasitoid on the eggs of H. armigera is Trichogrammatoidea armigera in maize (Rimbing et al., 2013). Hassan (1993) stated that local parasitoid species are better because these species have adapted to the local environment. Selecting a parasitoid strain is an important step for successful biological control (Hassan 1993; Sigsgaard et al., 2017). Each parasitoid strain showed different levels of parasitization in the same host species.

Released parasitoid dispersal determines the success that the distance dispersal radius should be measured to determine the number of parasitoid release spots, distribution pattern of the parasitoid and the dose of the parasitoid can be determined for more effective results (Knipling 1992). Inundated release of parasitoids performance if governed by parasitoid behavior, its ability of the parasitoid to find a host, the pattern of distribution of the parasitoid, the time of release and the dose of the released parasitoid (Hassan 1993; Jalali and Singh, 2006; Marwoto 2010). Dispersal pattern holds essential practical and theoretical importance (Southwood and Henderson, 2000). To date, proper strategy for optimal release of parasitoid T. armigera remains unknown. This study examined the parasitoid ability of T. armigera to H. armigera eggs after release, distribution of parasitoids and distribution patterns of parasitoids.
Parasitoids were released to corn plants in Minahasa, North Sulawesi, Indonesia at an altitude of 727 meters above sea level. The point of release was at 01°18'17.2"N and 12°48' 54.04"E. The temperature in the Entomology Laboratory of the Faculty of Agriculture at 07.00 AM was 26.71±0.611°C and 28.05±0.86°C at 02.00 PM. The experiment was carried out from May to October 2016.
T. armigera parasitoid propagation
Green beans granules were ground as Corcyra cephalonica (Stainton) feed (Rimbing et al., 2013). H. armigera eggs collected from the field were incubated in the laboratory. The egg parasitoid hatch out from incubated eggs were utilized to parasitize C. cephalonica eggs from the first day and continuously cultured on C. Cephalonica eggs until the 7th generation. T. armigera took 1-2 days to parasitize C. cephalonica eggs. Black C. cephalonica eggs that hatched were put into glass tubes with 5 × 20 cm in diameter and 10% honey was smeared as food for the parasitoids. ± 100 UV irradiated (for 45 minutes) eggs of C. Cephalonica were glued on 2 × 8 cm white cardboard and then kept in a glass tube containing parasitoids.

Parasitoid release on corn plants

Two parasitoid release plots and one no parasitoid release plot were mentained. The distance between parasitoid release plots with no release was ± 100 m, while the distance between release plots was 50 m. in a hectare corn crop, then demarked  into a circle area of 254 m2 as an experimental plot. The release was made at the center of the experimental plot. Helicoverpa. armigera eggs were collected  at 4 radial distance of 1, 3, 6 and 9 m from the parasitoid released point with four replications at the east, west, south and north areas  of both parasitoid released and unreleased plot (Fig 1).

Fig 1: T. armigera parasitoid distribution map. •=Parasitoid release point.

The release of 1000 individual parasitoids per 254 m2 was carried out twice during the generative phase shown by corn silk on the cob. The first release was on 45 DAP and the second was on 52 DAP at 06.30 AM. Cardboard of 2 × 8 cm in size containing parasitized C. cephalonica eggs was inserted in a pipe which end was covered with perforated gauze for the parasitoid to come out, while the other end was covered with cloth without the parasitoid imago coming out. Pipes of 5 cm in diameters and a length of 40 cm were placed in the center of the experimental plot using bamboo as support poles of 1.30 m height where pipes were put. After the release of the parasitoids, within 3-day interval, H. armigera eggs were collected from each radius distance. Six plants with corn silk were selected at each radius distance to obtain H. armigera eggs, while at a radius of 1 m, only 2 plants were taken due to insufficient population. H. armigera eggs from collected cobs were brushed from  corn silk in a pattriplate and observed for parasitoid emergence. in the laboratory. The parasitization rate of H. armigera eggs is described as follows:

P = Parasitization.
n = Number of parasitized eggs.
N = Total eggs of H. armigera.

Data analysis

Varian analysis followed with Duncan’s multiple range test (DMRT) at p<0.05 were employed to examine the parasitization of T. armigera on its eggs using SPSS program version 23, while distribution pattern was examined using by Morsita, Krebs’s formula (1978):

The population of H. armigera eggs

Each H. armgera eeg was put on the corn silk during the generative phase shown by yellowish white that turned to black after being parasitized. H. armigera egg population was found in all plant ages as treatment, with the highest population density in 45 DAP (Table 1). H. armigera eggs were laid on the corn silk, with a dominant population of 2 eggs per each. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) on the number of eggs of H. armigera in maize plots showed a significant difference p<0.017.

Table 1: Number of H. armigera eggs in corn fields.

Paratisization of T. armigera parasitoid

The release of parasitoid T. armigera cultured on eggs of C. cephalonica increased the per cent d parasitization on H. armgera eggs. Analysis of variance showed a significant effect on parasitization of H. armigera eggs p<0.005. Parasitization of the released parasitoid plot was higher than that of the no-release plot due to increased T. armigera parasitoids population. Parasitoid release of 45 DAP and 52 DAP parasitoids increased to 54.84 and 64.89% parasitization, respectively. However, at 45 DAP, a decrease by 25.69% was confirmed. Parasitoids parasitized the eggs H. armigera 45 DAP at higher rate due to varied plant ages and corn silk still undergoing peak development from pink to dark red 95%, where the female insect H. armigera prefers to lay eggs on such corn silk. At 52 DAP release, only 60% pink corn silk was found and the rest was blackish brown to black which was less preferred by H. armigera to lay eggs. Higher host egg density relates to more parasitic egg. High host density allows parasitoids to easily find hosts and increased the parasitization (Vinson 1977). Besides phenological factors, some microclimate factors, parasitoid survival and release time intervals also have contributions.

During the study up to 21 DAP until the harvest, dry season occurred, except 2 days before the release of the parasitoid at 45 DAP since heavy rain for 2 consecutive days occurred and the ground was covered with rickshaws. The microclimate on 45 DAP was cooler because of heavy rain received for 2 consecutive days before release and was more suitable for parasitoids, resulting in higher parasitization than on 52 DAP. Parasitoids are poikilo thermal organisms which body temperature depends on the temperature of the surrounding environment. Changes in air temperature affects metabolic processes of the insect’s body which affects the parasitization. Geetha and Balakrishnan (2011) found cooler microclimate affecting parasitoid Trichogramma chilonis Ishii parasitization, resulting in better dispersion. It is likely that on 52 DAP, the air temperature increased and caused weaker parasitoid activity to host eggs. The parasitization of Trichogrammatoidea lutea Girault increased from 21 to 27°C and decreased at 30°C. Optimum parasitization of T. lutea against H. armigera eggs was highest at 27°C (58 %) (Mawela et al., 2013). The longer the age of imago of the parasitoid T. armigera, the higher the total parasitization, while the shorter the lifespan of the parasitoid results in lower total parasitoid of the eggs of C. cephalonica (Rimbing et al., 2013). Insects’ activities including parasitoids are faster and more efficient at high temperatures, but the life of the parasitoids is shorter (Mavi and Tupper, 2004). How temperature and humidity affected parasitoid T. armigera was not specifically analyzed in this study. According to Hunt et al., (2001), plant environments at high humidity are more likely to be visited by insects than those with low humidity.

The release of parasitoids on 52 DAP occurred while the corn silk of the surrounding corn crops was still blooming between 40 to 45 DAP. It is hypothesized that the parasitoids released on 52 DAP migrated to corn plants which silk was still blooming. Corn silk still blooms pink and the egg population is high. The impact of the migration of parasitoids caused the parasitoid on 52 DAP might be resulted in low parasitization. On the other hand, the low parasitization released on 52 DAP could predict that most H. armigera eggs were 3 days old. Rimbing et al., (2013) explained that egg aged 3 day showed drastic decrease in parasitization. Older T. armigera parasitoids decrease the parasitization. The release of parasitoids should be at intervals of 3 days to increase parasitization since H. armigera lays eggs gradually.

The parasitoid dose of 1000 individuals per 254 m2 equivalent to 40,000 individuals ha-1 was able to increase the parasitization of H. armigera eggs. Release of parasitoid Trichogrammatoidea bactrae-bactrae Nagaraja 500,000 individuals ha-1 resulted in parasitized eggs of Etiella sp. of 18.77 and 44.04% (Marwoto and Supriyantin, 1999). On the contrary, the release of T. armigera on maize plants with low parasitoid doses resulted in the maximum parasitization of H. armigera eggs of between 38.57 and 51.91% (Table 2). Prior to the release of parasitoids, the quality of the parasitoid needs to be examined, including its parasitization characteristics and the lifespan of parasitoid. The life span of imago T. armigera was 4 days on eggs of C. Cephalonica cultured on mung bean bran, whereas those cultured with corn bran only had one day parasitoid life. Parasitization of parasitoids in eggs of C. Cephalonica cultured on mung bean bran was higher than in corn bran (Rimbing et al., 2013).

The dispersal of T. armigera parasitoids

After 3 days of release, the parasitoids reached H. armigera eggs to be parasitized. The parasitoid release plot was higher without the release of parasitoids. Based on the parasitization of eggs of H. armigera and its tilapia confirmed by the Morisita Id index>1, the spatial pattern of the parasitoid T. armigera followed the clustering pattern. The analysis of variance on the dispersal range of the parasitoids showed insignificant gap; release 45 DAP p>0.575, 52 DAP p>0.448; without parasitoid release 45 DAP p>0.920, 52 DAP p>0.853.

T. armigera was able to disburse  up to 9 m from the release point even reaching >9 m (Fig 2). Geetha and Balakrishnan (2011) mentioned that the distribution of the parasitoid T. chilonis could reach 30 m, but even distribution occurs at a radius of 10 m. The distribution of the parasitoid T. armigera is rather active. Passive parasitization accumulates in cardinal directions due to the wind. During the study, weak wind blew from the southeast. Chen and Chiang (1993) wrote that parasitoids Trichogramma spp. tend to fly against the wind. Parasitoids dispersed in all directions to the north, south, east and west, meaning that the parasitoids did not gather in one of the cardinal directions. The highest parasitization trend was found in 45 DAP and 52 DAP in all cardinal directions (Fig 3). Analysis of variance results was not significantly different; plot of release 45 DAP p>0.92, 52 DAP p>0.97; without release 45 HST p>0.97; 52 DAP p>0.94.

Fig 2: The dispersal of T. armigera on corn.

Fig 3: Parasitization of T. armigera against H. armigera eggs in the cardinal directions.

The parasitoid T. armigera tends to cluster in release and no release plots. The plot of the release of parasitoids with clusters leads to regular dispersal. Smaller Morisita index indicates lower clustering population (Rosenberg and Anderson, 2011). The clustering pattern was homogeneous corn ecosystem, with minimum individual competition. The distribution of T. armigera parasitoids on maize is in clusters, requiring the use of regular or systematic sampling method.

The distribution range of the parasitoid T. armigera and parasitization showed that the number of parasitoid release points in maize is 40 ha-1. The release of T. chilonis at 100 stations ha-1 can suppress Chilo sacchariphagus Boj infestations, increasing the sugarcane production by 23% (Marquier et al., 2008). Parasitoid release did not determine the number of stations. In 8-time releases of Trichogramma sp. with a dose of 100,000 individuals ha-1, no significant difference in the mortality of shoot borer eggs and sugar cane stem borer was found (Nurindah et al., 2016). This poor result might be due to in appropriate  number of release points and low-quality parasitoids.
The release of 1000 T. armigera parasitoids per 254 m2 increased the parasitization of H. armigera eggs on corn plant. The increase in parasitization on 45 DAP reached 51.91% and 38.57% on 52 DAP. The released parasitoids were evenly dispersed to all radius, even up to a radius of 9 m. The parasitoid T. armigera moved actively and dispersed evenly to north, east, south and west directions. The distribution of T. armigera was clustered for more systematic parasitoid monitoring. Based on the dispersal radius of the parasitoid, 40 release points ha-1 were determined as the release points of T. armigera in corn crops for effective management of cob borer.

  1. Chen, C.C. and Chiang, H.C. (1993), Population fluctuations and dispersal of Trichogramma spp. in corn fields. Chinese Journal of Entomology. 13: 305-318.

  2. Geetha, N. and Balakrishnan, R. (2011). Temporal and spatial of laboratory-reared Trichogramma chilonis Ishii in open field. Journal of Entomology. 8: 164-173. DOI: 10.3923/ je.2022.164.173.

  3. Hassan, S.A. (1993). The mass rearing and utilization of Trichogramma  to control Lepidoptera pest achievement and outbreak. Pesticide Science. 37: 387-391.

  4. Hunt, T.E., Higley, L.G., Witkowski, J.F., Young, L.J. and Hellmich, R.L. (2001). Dispersal of adult European corn borer (Lepidoptera: Crambidae) within and proximal to irrigated and non-irrigated corn. Journal of Economic Entomology. 94: 1369-1377. DOI: 10.1603/0022-0493-94.6.1369.

  5. Jalali, S.K. and Singh, S.P. (2006). Biological control of Chilo partellus using egg parasitoid Trichogramma chilonis and Bacillus thuringiensis. Indian Journal of Agricultural Research. 40: 184-189.

  6. Knipling, E.F. (1992). Principles of Insect Parasitism Analysed from New Perspectives. Practical Implications for Regulating Insect Populations by Biological Means. USDA Agriculture. Hand Book No. 693. USDA-ARS. pp. 349.

  7. Krebs. (1978). Ecology. The Experimental Analysis of Distribution and Abundance. Third edition, Harper and Row Distribution, Harper and Row Publisher. New York. pp. 653.

  8. Marquier, M., Clain, C., Tabone, E., Goebel, R. and Roux, E. (2008). Comparative Effectiveness of Two Release Frequencies and Two Release Point Densities of Trichogramma chilonis Ishii (Hyemenoptera: Trichogrammatidae) to Control Sugarcane Stem Borer in la reunion. In: International Congress of Entomology (ICE). Hal Id: hal-02814676. pp. 427-435.

  9. Marwoto and Supriyatin. (1999). Spreadability and efficacy of the parasitoid Trichogrammatoidea bactrae bactrae in controlling soybean pod borer. Agriculture Research. 19: 15-21.

  10. Marwoto, (2010). The prospect of Trichogrammatoidea bactrae-bactrae Nagaraja (Hymenoptera) parasitoids as natural agent in controlling soybean borer, Etiella sp. Agricultural Innovative Development. 3: 274-288.

  11. Mavi, H.S. and Tupper, G.J. (2004). Agrometeorology: Principles and Application of Climate Studies in agriculture. CRC. Press. pp. 447. 

  12. Mawela, K.V., Kfir, R. and Krüger, K. (2013). Effect of temperature and host species on parasitism, development time and sex ratio of the egg parasitoid Trichogrammatoidea lutea Girault (Hymenoptera: Trichogrammatidae). Biological Control. 64: 211-216.

  13. Nurindah, Sunarto, D.A. and Sujak. (2016). Evaluation of the release of Trichogramma spp. for the control of sugarcane shoot and stem borer. Indonesia Journal Entomology. 13: 107- 116. 

  14. Rimbing, J., Pelealu, J., Maramis, R. and Tulung, M. (2013). Response of Trichogrammatoidea armigera Nagaraja parasitoid to Corcyra cephalonica eggs cultured in some feed media. Asian Transaction on Basic and Applied Sciences. 3: 8-12.

  15. Rosenberg, M.S. and Anderson, C.D. (2011). Passege: Pattern analysis, spatial statistics and geographic exegesis. Methods in Ecology and Evolution. 2: 229-232. DOI: 10.1111/j.2041-210X.2010.00081.x.

  16. Sigsgaard, L., Herz, A., Korsgaard, M. and Wuhrer, B. (2017). Mass Release of Trichogramma evanescens and T. cacoeciae can reduce damage by the apple codling moth Cydia pomonella in organic orchards under pheromone disruption. Insect. 8: 41. DOI: 10.3390/insects8020041.

  17. Southwood, T.R.E. and Henderson, P.A. (2000). Ecological Methods. 3rd ed. Blackwell Science. pp. 575.    

  18. Vinson, S.B. (1977). Behavioural Chemicals in the Augmentation of Natural Enemies. In: [Ridgway, R.L., Vinson, S.B. (eds.)], Biological Control by Augmentation of Natural Enemies. Plenum Press. 

Editorial Board

View all (0)