Milk yield of two camel breeds, Majahim and Sofor, over a 10-month period is presented in Fig 3. Overall, the Majaheem she-camels consistently produced a higher milk yield than the Sofor she-camels throughout the entire 10-month lactation period. Both Majaheem and Sofor breeds reached their peak milk yield in month 5. The Majaheem camels peaked at approximately 7.5 kg of milk per day, while the Majaheem camels peaked at around 5.57 kg per day. After peaking in month 5, the milk yield for both types of camels steadily declined for the remainder of the 10-month period. Collectively, the data clearly demonstrates that the Majaheem breed is a superior milk producer compared to the Sofor breed in terms of milk yield across the entire 10-month lactation cycle.
Chemical milk composition
The study found significant differences in the milk composition between Majaheem and Sofor camels (Table 1). Majaheem milk had a significantly higher (P<0.05) average fat percentage (2.38%) compared to Sofor camels (1.79%). Majaheem milk had a higher average (8.25%) of SNF than Sofor camels (8.00%). There was no significant difference in the protein percentage between the two breeds. Majaheem milk averaged 3.03% and Sofor camels averaged 2.97% of total protein. Majaheem milk showed a significantly higher (P<0.05) average lactose percentage (4.42%) compared to Sofor milk (4.33%). Majaheem milk had a significantly higher average mineral content (0.67%) than Sofor milk (0.53%). There were no significant differences in milk density (P=0.06) or freezing point (P=0.05) between the two breeds.
Physiological parameters, productive and reproductive parameters
Physiological parameters, productive and reproductive parameters of Majaheem and Sofor she-camel breeds is presented in Table 2. The Sofor camels had significantly (P<0.03) lower rectal temperature (37.52
oC) compared to the Majaheem camels (37.73
oC). There were no significant differences in pulse rate or blood oxygen saturation (SPO2) between the two breeds. The Sofor she-camels required a significantly (P<0.0001) lower number of inseminations per pregnancy (2.16) than the Majaheem she-camels (2.75). The Majaheem she-camels had a significantly (P<0.01) longer lactation period (315.0 days) than the Sofor she-camels (290.0 days). Majaheem she-camels demonstrated a significantly higher daily milk production (4.80 L) compared to the Sofor camels (3.50 L). There was no significant difference in open days between the two breeds.
In conclusion, the data indicates that while Sofor camels have a better reproductive efficiency (fewer inseminations needed for pregnancy), the Majaheem she-camels are superior in terms of milk production and have a longer lactation period. Additionally, Sofor she-camels have a significantly lower rectal temperature, which may indicate a difference in their physiological response.
Hematological and plasma biochemical analysis
Concerning to hematology investigation (Table 3), the analysis revealed significant differences in all measured blood parameters between the Majaheem and Sofor breeds. The Sofor she-camels consistently showed higher values compared to the Majaheem she-camels. The Sofor camels had a significantly (P<0.01) higher RBCs count (8.10×10
6/μl) than the Majaheem camels (7.50×10
6/μl). The packed cell volume (PCV) was significantly (P<0.05) higher in Sofor camels (28.3%) compared to Majaheem camels (25.10%). Sofor camels had a significantly higher hemoglobin concentration (12.20 g/dl) than Majaheem camels (11.30 g/dl). The Sofor breed showed a significantly (P<0.0001) higher total white blood cell count (16.90×10
3/μl) than the Majaheem breed (15.80×10
3/μl). In summary, the Sofor camels demonstrated significantly higher values for all hematological parameters, suggesting a distinctive physiological difference between the two breeds.
The values of plasma biochemical profiles of Majaheem and Sofor breeds are presented in Table 4. The Majaheem group had significantly lower values in all of plasma biochemical profiles if compared to Sofor group. The analysis revealed several significant differences in plasma biochemistry between the Majaheem and Sofor breeds. The Sofor camels generally had higher values for most of the measured parameters. Sofor camels had a significantly higher total protein concentration (6.55 g/dl) compared to Majaheem camels (6.15 g/dl). Both urea (25.0 mg/dl vs. 18.5 mg/dl) and creatinine (2.0 mg/dl vs. 1.60 mg/dl) concentrations were significantly higher in the Sofor breed. The Sofor breed had a significantly higher blood glucose level (125.0 mg/dl) than the Majaheem breed (111.5 mg/dl). Creatine kinase (CK) activity was significantly higher in Sofor camels (82.0 U/l) than in Majaheem camels (72.5 U/l). Lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) activity was also significantly higher in Sofor camels (795.0 U/l) compared to Majaheem camels (730.0 U/l). The Sofor breed had a highly significant higher iron concentration (92.0 µg/dl) than the Majaheem breed (83.0 µg/dl). γ-glutamyl transferase (GGT) activity was significantly higher in Sofor camels (70.0 U/l) than in Majaheem camels (63.5 U/l). The values of aspartate aminotransferase (AST), alanine amino-transferase (ALT) and Copper were not different between the two breeds.
Based on the comprehensive results presented across the provided (Fig 3 and Table 1-2), the most striking finding was the clear distinction in milk productivity between the Majaheem and Sofor breeds. The Majaheem camels exhibit a significantly higher daily milk yield, peaking at approximately 7.5 kg in the fifth month of lactation, than Sofor breed. This suggests that the Majaheem is a high-yielding dairy breed with a strong initial lactation curve as indicated in other studies (
El-Hanafy et al., 2023). In addition, the Majaheem camels have a significantly longer lactation period (315 days) compared to the Sofor camels (290 days). This implies that Majaheem camels are ideal for high-volume milk production and long-term milk supply. In terms of reproductive efficiency, the Sofor breed demonstrates a significant advantage, requiring fewer inseminations per pregnancy (
Mohammed and Al-Mutairi 2012). This indicates higher fertility and this could make them a more economically efficient choice for large-scale breeding programs.
Both breeds follow a typical lactation curve, with milk production starting at a moderate level, peaking and then gradually declining. Milk yield for both breeds peaks in the fifth month of lactation. The peak yield for Majaheem camels is approximately 7.5 kg/day, while for Sofor camels, it is around 5.5 kg/day.
The figure highlights the clear superiority of the Majaheem breed in milk production as indicated in other study (
El-Hanafy et al., 2023). For every month of lactation shown, Majaheem camels consistently produce a higher daily milk yield than Sofor camels. Majaheem camels begin their lactation with a daily yield of over 2.5 kg, while Sofor camels start below 2 kg. The gap between the two breeds widens as they approach their peak production. The difference is most pronounced at the peak of lactation in month 5. The consistent and statistically significant difference in daily milk yield over the entire lactation period confirms that Majaheem camels are the preferred choice for milk production. The lactation curve for Majaheem is not only higher at the peak but also maintains a higher level of production for a longer duration, contributing to a greater total milk yield over the curve of the lactation.
Milk composition
The results of milk composition indicate clear differences in milk composition between Majaheem and Sofor she-camels under an extensive management system (Table 1). This study demonstrates that under extensive management system, Majaheem camels produce milk with a significantly higher concentration of key components like fat, lactose and minerals compared to Sofor camels. These results are consistent with previous studies that have noted variations in milk composition among camel breeds, often linked to genetics, diet and environmental conditions (
Elamin and Wilcox 1992;
El-Hanafy et al., 2023). The extensive management system used in this study, where animals had access to natural grazing, likely played a role in the observed differences. The higher fat and mineral content in Majaheem camels could be a genetic trait that allows them to better utilize the nutrients available in their grazing environment, leading to a richer milk composition.
These findings have several implications for the value and potential use of milk from each breed (
Elamin and Wilcox 1992;
El-Hanafy et al., 2023). The most notable finding is the significantly higher fat content in Majaheem camel milk compared to Sofor camel milk (P<0.0001). This difference is substantial and suggests that Majaheem camels may be more suitable for products where milk fat is a key component, such as butter or ghee. This higher fat content, along with the significant differences in solids-non-fat (SNF), lactose and minerals, contributes to the overall higher density of Majaheem milk, although the difference in density itself was not significant at the P<0.05 level. The significant differences in SNF, lactose and minerals further highlight the nutritional superiority of Majaheem milk in this study. Higher SNF indicates a richer concentration of non-fat components, which are crucial for the nutritional value of milk. The higher mineral content in Majaheem milk is also a significant finding, as minerals are essential for both human nutrition and the overall quality of the milk. Interestingly, protein content was not significantly different between the two breeds. This suggests that while Majaheem camels may produce milk with higher fat and mineral content, the protein yield per unit of milk is similar between the two breeds. This is a crucial point for dairy processing, as protein is a key ingredient in cheese and other products. The lack of a significant difference in freezing point and density, while other compositional factors were different, suggests a complex interplay between the various milk components. The freezing point is influenced by the concentration of lactose and minerals and while both were higher in Majaheem milk, the overall effect on the freezing point was not large enough to be statistically significant, possibly due to the small sample size or other unmeasured variables.
Physiological, reproductive and productive traits
The results presented in Table 2 reveal significant differences in physiological, reproductive and productive traits between Majaheem and Sofor camels under the extensive management system. These findings have important implications for understanding the overall performance and adaptability of these breeds. Majaheem camels had a higher average rectal temperature (37.73
oC) compared to Sofor camels (37.52
oC) (P<0.03). This significant difference might suggest a subtle variation in thermoregulatory mechanisms between the two breeds, possibly reflecting their genetic adaptations to the environment due to black color coat. While Majaheem camels had a slightly higher pulse rate and a lower SpO2, these differences were not statistically significant (P<0.07 and P<0.08 respectively). This suggests that both breeds are generally similar in their baseline cardiovascular and respiratory functions under these conditions. The slight trends, however, may warrant further investigation with a larger sample size.
A highly significant finding is that Sofor camels required significantly fewer inseminations per pregnancy (2.16) compared to Majaheem camels (2.75) (P<0.0001). This indicates that Sofor camels have better reproductive efficiency, which is a crucial factor for the economic
viability of a breeding program. Fewer inseminations translate to lower costs and shorter breeding intervals, making Sofor camels potentially more profitable from a reproductive standpoint. This could be attributed to higher milk production in Majaheem camels with an inverse relationship between milk production and reproductive performance
(Antanaitis et al., 2024). No significant differences were found in the number of open days between the two breeds. This suggests that both breeds have similar reproductive cycles and that the difference in insemination success is the primary factor affecting their reproductive efficiency, rather than the length of their reproductive cycles. Majaheem camels demonstrated superior milk-producing capabilities. Majaheem camels significantly outperformed Sofor camels in key dairy metrics under the extensive management system. The Majaheem demonstrated superior productivity with an average daily yield of 4.80 L, substantially higher than the Sofor’s 3.50 L. Furthermore, Majaheem maintained this production for a considerably longer lactation period (315 days) compared to the Sofor (290 days). These strong differences indicate that Majaheem is the more suitable and productive dairy breed of the two.
Hematological and biochemical traits
The observed differences in milk yield and reproductive efficiency are well-supported by the hematological and biochemical traits (Table 3 and 4). The data reveals several significant differences in blood characteristics, which can offer insights into the physiological state and health of each breed under the extensive management system (Table 3). Surprisingly, the Majaheem camels had a slightly but significantly lower RBC count (7.50×10
6/µl) compared to Sofor camels (8.10×10
6/µl). Correspondingly, Majaheem camels also showed significantly lower values for both packed cell volume (PCV) and hemoglobin (Hb) compared to Sofor camels. The PCV was 25.10% in Majaheem versus 28.3% in Sofor (P<0.05) and Hb was 11.30 g/dl versus 12.20 g/dl (P<0.01). These three parameters (RBC, PCV and Hb) are all related to the oxygen-carrying capacity of the blood. The consistently lower values in Majaheem camels suggest that their blood is less dense in red blood cells and carries less oxygen per unit volume compared to Sofor camels. This could be a physiological adaptation or a reflection of nutritional status. Given that Majaheem camels are noted for higher milk production, their body may be prioritizing nutrient allocation to milk synthesis over red blood cell production, although this is a hypothesis that would require further investigation. Alternatively, it might simply be a breed-specific trait.
Sofor camels had a significantly higher average WBCs count (16.90×10
3/µl) compared to Majaheem camels (15.80×10
3/µl). A higher WBCs count is often an indicator of an ongoing inflammatory response, infection, or stress. The significantly higher count in Sofor camels, while potentially within a normal range, suggests that they might be experiencing a higher level of physiological stress or are more prone to subclinical infections compared to the Majaheem breed under the conditions of this study. It is also possible that this is a normal breed-specific difference in immune system activity.
The lower blood concentrations of glucose, urea, creatinine, total protein and key metabolic enzymes like lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) and creatine kinase (CK) in Majaheem camels strongly suggest a higher basal metabolic rate (Table 4). Lactation is a highly energy-demanding process and the decreased levels of glucose and protein are likely a direct physiological response to meet the demands of producing a greater volume of milk. The lower levels of urea and creatinine could be linked to increased protein anabolism, which is characteristic of highly productive animals. In conclusion, this comprehensive analysis of physiological, reproductive and biochemical parameters confirms that Majaheem and Sofor camels represent distinct breeds with unique adaptive and productive characteristics. These findings are crucial for developing targeted breeding strategies and optimizing camel management for specific economic and ecological objectives.