The microstructure and muscle fiber diameters of breast muscle and thigh muscle
As shown in Fig 1, at the age of 21 days, Compared with the Con, the muscle fibers of breast and thigh muscle were thinner with smaller cross-section area, tighter arrangement and less connective tissues between muscle bundles in the Exp. I and Exp. II (Fig 1E, 1F, 1I and 1J). The microstructure of the breast muscle and thigh muscle in Exp. III had no significant change (Fig 1M and 1N). At the age of 42 days, compared with the Con, the microstructure of breast and thigh muscle in Exp. I was not significantly different (Fig 1G and 1H). The microstructure of breast muscle in the Exp. II and Exp. III presented a tighter arrangement, lesser cross-sectional area and connective tissue between the muscle bundles (Fig 1K and 1O). The thigh muscle fibers in the Exp. II were also obviously thinner and tighter in arrangement (Fig 1L). In the Exp. III, the arrangement of thigh muscle fiber became tighter and connective tissues became less between muscle bundles (Fig 1P).
When the broiler chickens were 21-day-old (Fig 1Q), no significant difference was observed in the fiber diameters of breast and thigh muscle among the 4 groups (breast muscle: 38.15±3.39, 35.71±3.31, 34.06±6.68, 34.78±3.46; thigh muscle: 34.68±2.99, 35.35±1.98, 30.90±4.51, 36.46±1.82). When the chickens were 42-day-old (Fig 1Q), the fiber diameters of breast muscle in the Exp. II and Exp. III were decreased by 13.75% and 13.30% compared with the Con (P<0.05). Compared with the Con, the Exp. I, Exp. III, the fiber diameters of breast muscle were decreased by 21.62%, 19.50% and 23.41% in the Exp. II (P<0.05).
Muscle is composed of many muscle fibers, the quantity and diameter of the muscle fibers will directly impact the growth of muscle and meat quality. Under the same conditions, more muscle fibers indicate a larger potential for muscle growth, while smaller muscle diameters with higher density suggest higher meat quality (
Felício et al., 2013). The morphological structure changes in quantity, diameter and density of muscle fibers are closely related to the composition of feed, the rising environment and the health situation of animals
(Mehri et al., 2016). In the current study, by adding 0.5% and 1.0% compound Chinese herbal medicines into the diet, the microstructure of breast muscle and thigh muscle of 21-day-old and 42-day-old broiler chickens were improved in pace with more muscle fibers and higher fiber density. This was mainly due to the active ingredients such as polysaccharides, saponin and others contained in the compound Chinese herbal medicines not only could improve the local immunity of the gastrointestinal tract, but also enhance the immune function and antioxidant capacity of the whole body
(Choi et al., 2014; Wu et al., 2016). This would, in turn, potentially provide a favorable environment for the proliferation of skeleton satellite cells (stem cells to produce muscle fibers) and inhibit the expression of genes correlated with cell apoptosis
(Liu et al., 2010) and then promote the growth of muscle fibers.
Meat quality of breast muscle and thigh muscle
The meat quality is mainly evaluated by indicators including pH value, water holding capacity, drip loss and cooking loss. Any change in the above indicators would directly impact the quality of chicken meat. The pH value of muscle is closely related to acidic substance contents and the water-holding capacity of muscle. An increase in pH value suggests less acidification degree of muscle and stronger water-holding capacity. In our study (Table 1), when the broiler chickens were 21-day-old, the pH
45min value of breast muscle in the Exp. I and Exp. II were increased by 4.01% and 3.84% compared with the Con (P<0.05). When the broiler chickens were 42-day-old, the pH
45min value of breast muscle was not significantly different among the 4 groups (P>0.05). The pH
45min value of thigh muscle in the Exp. I was increased by 4.27 % compared with the Con (P<0.05), but no significant difference was found when compared with the Exp. II and Exp. III (P>0.05).
Water holding capacity, drip loss and cooking loss are closely related to the protein amount in the muscle
(Kapase et al., 2021). An increase in these indicators indicates stronger water retention capacity and higher protein amounts in the muscle, which means more nutrients. As shown in Table 1, when the broiler chickens were 21-day-old, the water-holding capacity of the thigh muscle in the Exp. II was increased by 9.06% and 23.87% compared with the Con and the Exp. III, respectively (P<0.05). When the broiler chickens were 42-day-old, the water-holding capacity of thigh muscle in the Exp. I and Exp. II were increased by 23.03% and 16.31% compared with the Con, respectively (P<0.05). When the broiler chickens were 21-day-old, the drip loss of breast muscle in the Exp. II was not different compared with the Con (P>0.05), while had a decrease of 28.92% and 27.86% compared with the Exp. I and Exp. III (P<0.05). The drip loss of thigh muscle in the Exp. I and Exp. II were decreased by 23.37% and 21.20 compared with the Con (P<0.05) and decreased by 27.32% and 25.26 % compared with the Exp. III (P<0.05). When the broiler chickens were 42-day-old, the drip loss of breast muscle in the Exp. I decreased by 25.10% compared with the Con (P<0.05). The drip loss of thigh muscle showed no significant difference among the 4 groups (P>0.05). When the broiler chickens were 21-day-old, there was no significant difference in the cooking loss of breast muscle among the 4 groups (P>0.05). The cooking loss of thigh muscle in the Exp. II was decreased by 15.88% and 13.16% compared with the Con and Exp. III, respectively (P<0.05). When the broiler chickens were 42-day-old, there was no significant difference in the cooking loss of breast muscle among the 4 groups (P>0.05). The cooking loss of thigh muscle in the Exp. I and II were decreased by 14.11% and 13.06%, compared with the Con, respectively (P<0.05). When the broiler chickens were 21-day-old, the water loss rate of breast muscle in the Exp. I and Exp. II were decreased by 11.35% and 17.56% compared with the Con (P<0.05). The water loss rate of thigh muscle in the Exp. I and Exp. II were decreased by 16.35% and 25.47% compared with the Con (P<0.05). When the broiler chickens were 42-day-old, the water loss rate of breast muscle in the Exp. II was decreased by 17.05%, 17.52% and 21.22% compared with the Con, Exp. I and Exp. III (P<0.05). The water loss rate of thigh muscle in the Exp. II was decreased by 18.41% and 11.56% compared with the Con and Exp. I (P<0.05). The water loss rate of thigh muscle in the Exp. III was decreased by 12.42% compared with the Con (P<0.05).
Shearing force is a reflection of muscle tenderness. Higher shearing force means lower muscle tenderness and weaker water retention capacity
(Li et al., 2010). As shown in Table 1, when the broiler chickens were 21-day-old, the shearing force of breast muscle had no significant difference among the 4 groups (P>0.05). The shearing force of thigh muscle in the Exp. I was decreased by 26.54% and 32.77% compared with the Con and Exp. II, respectively (P<0.05). When the broiler chickens were 42-day-old, the shearing force of breast muscle in the Exp. I was decreased by 46.61% compared with the Con (P<0.05). The shearing force of thigh muscle showed no significant difference among the 4 groups (P>0.05).
Many studies have reported that the addition of the compound Chinese herbal medicines in the diet improved the meat quality as well as increased the growth performance of animals. The research of
Zhang et al. (2012) on pigs showed that the addition of 0.2% Ligustrum lucidum extracts in the diet significantly decreased the drip loss, cooking loss and shearing force of longissimus dorsi muscle, thus improved the meat quality. The study of
Ma et al. (2016) on Hetian chickens indicated that the addition of 1.0% compound Chinese herbal medicines composed of astragalus and Atractylodes in the diet significantly increased the muscle rate and pH
45min value of thigh muscle and decreased drip loss and shearing force, which resulted in the improvement of meat quality. Our research results indicated that the addition of 0.5% and 1.0% compound Chinese herbal medicines improved the meat quality of broiler chickens. The main reason may be that the active ingredients such as polysaccharides, saponin and others in the compound Chinese herbal medicines increased the activities of antioxidants and other enzymes in the energy metabolism pathways in the muscle fiber (
Sun and Wang, 2010), enhanced the antioxidant activities of myocytes, regulated energy metabolism and some biochemical processes of the cell and then reduced cellular proteolysis, thereby affected the pH value, water holding capacity and shearing force of muscle (
Kadam and Ambadkar, 2022). In addition, astragalus and Poria cocos in the compound Chinese herbal medicines increased the amount of proteins and essential fatty acids in muscle by regulated the fat metabolism in the liver and amino acid metabolism in the muscle of the chickens
(Meng et al., 2016), thereby contributed to the nutritional quality of muscle.
Correlation analysis
According to our research on the correlation between muscle fiber diameter and muscle water holding capacity, drip loss, cooking loss, shearing force, pH
45min value and water loss rate, it was found that the muscle fiber diameter of the breast muscle in 21-day-old broiler showed a significant positive correlation with muscle water holding capacity (P<0.05), while the muscle water holding capacity of the thigh muscle showed a significant negative correlation with drip loss, shearing force and water loss rate (P<0.05), the water loss rate of thigh muscle showed a significant positive correlation with drip loss and cooking loss (P<0.05) (Fig 2A and 2B). For the breast muscle of 42-day-old broiler, the correlation between the water holding capacity showed a significant negative correlation with water loss rate (P<0.05); the water holding capacity of thigh muscle showed a significant negative correlation with water loss rate (P<0.05) and showed a significant positive correlation with pH
45min value (
p<0.05). The correlation between muscle pH
45min value showed a significant negative correlation with water loss rate (P<0.05) (Fig 2C and 2D).
Many studies have found a significant correlation between muscle fiber diameter or cross-sectional area and muscle quality. Smaller muscle fiber diameter or cross-sectional area can increase muscle water holding capacity, decrease muscle drip loss, cooking loss and shearing force, improve muscle tenderness and enhance muscle palatability, which mainly determined by the number of fiber types IIA and IIB (
Mehmood and Zhang, 2020). Current study found, at 21-day-old, the diameter of muscle fibers breast muscle was significantly positively correlated with water holding capacity, while the water holding capacity of thigh muscle was significantly negatively correlated with drip loss, shearing force and water loss rate. At 42-day-old, the water holding capacity of thigh muscle is positively correlated with pH4
5min value and negatively correlated with water loss rate and pH
45min value is also negatively correlated with water loss rate. This indicates that the smaller the diameter of muscle fibers and the higher the density, accompanied by stronger water holding capacity and an appropriate increase in pH
45min value and the smaller the shearing force, drip loss and water loss rate, resulting in better muscle quality. Our results are consistent with previous research reports and the main reason may be related to muscle fiber type and protein content
(Huo et al., 2022; Zhang et al., 2020).
Our research shows that adding an appropriate amount of Chinese herbal medicine can affect muscle development and improve muscle quality, but the composition of Chinese herbal medicine is complex and it is not clear which ingredient produces the improvement effect. More importantly, there are many types of Chinese herbal medicine and it is unclear which Chinese herbal medicine formula can effectively improve muscle quality. Therefore, more research is needed on the application of Chinese herbal medicine in animal husbandry.