A total of 4,253 samples from 52 districts and 177 villages were used in this study from five Indian states: Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Goa, Punjab and Rajasthan (Fig 1). Cumulative seropositivity was found to be 20.20% (859/4253). [17.47(16.11-18.89)] was found to be on the higher side and was significant (χ2 = 488.5, p =<0.0001) (Table 1).
State wise prevalence
Andhra Pradesh is part of the southern zone of India. 2070 buffaloes were tested and showed seropositivity of 11.35% [7.3 (95% CI: 5.81- 8.96%)] from 84 villages covering 20 districts.
Aruna and Babu (1992) have reported 21.1% (236/1121) seropositivity in buffaloes from Andhra Pradesh. A study involving both cattle and buffalo tested for IBR showed 27.4% (423/1541) seropositivity in Andhra Pradesh
(Sarumathi et al., 2002). In 2012, serological investigation for IBR by ELISA in cattle and buffaloes showed 16.26% (237/1458) seropositivity, reported in Andhra Pradesh by
Trangadia et al. (2012). In 2023, randomly collected milk-producing buffalo serum samples showed 27% (27/100) seropositivity in Andhra Pradesh
(Patil et al. 2023b). In another study, 41.01% (89/217) seropositivity was reported in buffaloes, particularly those belonging to the Palnadu district of Andhra Pradesh
(Kalavathi et al., 2024).
Karnataka is also in the southern zone. Two hundred and twenty-three buffaloes were tested and showed seropositivity of 12.11% [8.17 (95% CI: 3.97-13.84%)] from 12 villages covering five districts. In 1996, buffalo samples collected from a slaughterhouse in Bangalore, Karnataka, showed 52.5% (530/1010) seropositivity in buffaloes
(Renukaradhya et al., 1996). In 2015, samples collected from buffaloes on dairy farms in Karnataka showed 51.22% (42/82) seropositivity
(Krishnamoorthy et al., 2015). In 2023, randomly collected milk-producing buffalo serum samples showed 54% (54/100) seropositivity in Andhra Pradesh
(Patil et al., 2023b).
Goa is also a part of the southern zone; 97 buffaloes were tested and showed seropositivity of 18.56% [15.58 (95% CI: 8.13-25.79%)] from 6 villages covering 2 districts. Not much data is available on the Goa region tested for IBR except for Patil
et al. (2022), who reported 22.31% (56/251) seropositivity in bovine serum samples.
Punjab is a part of the northern zone in India. One thousand and six buffaloes were tested and showed seropositivity of 44.43% [45.33 (95% CI: 41.83-48.87%)] from 40 villages covering 13 districts. In 2002, a study conducted in organized and unorganized dairy farms in the state of Punjab showed 17.48% seropositivity in buffaloes
(Dhand et al., 2002). In 2004, a study conducted in two phases showed 33.3% seropositivity in buffaloes
(Aradhana et al., 2004). A study involving the history of buffalo abortions from 2 dairy farms in Punjab showed 54.50% seropositivity
(Dhami et al., 2008). In 2023, randomly collected milk-producing buffalo serum samples showed 58% (58/100) seropositivity in Punjab
(Patil et al. 2023b).
Rajasthan is a part of the western zone in India. 857 buffaloes were tested and showed seropositivity of 15.40% [11.96 (95% CI: 9.36-14.91%)] from 35 villages covering 12 districts. In 2023, randomly collected milk-producing buffalo serum samples showed 33% (33/100) seropositivity in Rajasthan
(Patil et al., 2023b).
Age wise prevalence
In the present study, buffaloes belonging to the age group of 5 to 10 years showed a higher seropositivity of 22.56% [20.19 (17.94-22.58)]. Buffaloes belonging to <5 years and >10 years showed 18.56% [15.58(13.87-17.41)] and 20.93% [18.31(12.09-25.99)] respectively (Table 2). Statistical analysis showed that the p-value is less than 0.05 and is significant (χ2 = 9.81, p = 0.0074). In 2021, Buffaloes belonging to age groups (years) of <2.5, 2.5–4.5, 4.5-6.5 and ≥ 6.5 showed seropositivity for IBR 41.38% (12/29), 69.64% (39/56), 58.51% (55/94) and 75.61% (31/41) respectively from Haryana state
(Farooq et al., 2021). In a study focusing on ≤ 3-year-old cattle belonging to the districts Tutak and Doğubeyazýt, IBR seropositivity was 3.39% and 1.70%, respectively, in turkey
(Aktaş et al., 2021). In 2022, a study in turkey cattle revealed that the 0-3 year old group had a seropositivity of 12.38% (14/113), the 4-6 year old group had a seropositivity of 28.12% (9/32) and the 7-9 year old group had a seropositivity of 53.3% (8/15)
(Alçay et al., 2022).
Hamdy et al. (2022) studied the sero-surveillance of IBR in cattle and buffalo belonging to the age groups <2, 2-4 and >4 and reported 19.81% (21/106), 21.90% (30/137) and 71.9% (41/57), respectively, in Egypt.
Ortiz-gonzález et al. (2022) accessed dairy herds in Columbia for IBR seroprevalence and reported that age groups belonging to < 1 year had 55.9% (100/179), 1-2 years had 48.8% (102/209), 2-4 years had 42.9% (48/112) and > 4 years had 65% (325/500).
Trinidad et al. (2024) focused their study on IBR/IPV in the regions of Peru and reported seropositivity in age groups of 2-5 years with 87.5% (70-80) and >5 years with 56.58% (43/76).
Kalavathi et al. (2024) reported IBR seropositivity of 17.86% (15/84), 41.76% (76/182) and 56.70 (55/97), which belongs to the age groups of <3 years, 3-7 years and >7 years in cattle and buffalo. Across different studies in the world, age groups that are typically 4-5 years old show higher seropositivity. The variation may be because the older animals are exposed to BoAHV-1 many times, leading to higher seropositivity rates.
Sex wise prevalence
In the present study, female buffaloes showed a higher IBR seropositivity of 20.85% [18.22 (16.74-19.77)] and male buffaloes showed an IBR seropositivity of 16.28% [12.97 (9.84-16.58)]. The statistical analysis was found to be significant (χ2 = 6.46, p = 0.011) (Table 2). In 2017, a study in Baghdad, Iraq, showed not much of a difference between IBR seropositivity, with males being 38.09% (8/21) and females being 41.34% (43/104).
(Nezzal et al., 2017). Kalavathi et al. (2024) reported the seropositivity of males at 14.29% (12/84) and females at 48.03% (134/279) in buffaloes and cattle. In 2016, reports of male buffaloes showed seropositivity of 11.11% (1/9) and female buffaloes showed seropositivity of 6% (2/33) in Chhattisgarh
(Samrath et al., 2016). In 2015, samples collected from cattle and buffaloes on dairy farms in Karnataka showed seropositivity of males being 57.89% (11/19) and females being 61.67% (333/540)
(Krishnamoorthy et al., 2015). In 2017, selected farms of Uttarakhand buffaloes showed seropositivity, with males being 25% (2/8) and females being 39.32% (35/89)
(Thakur et al., 2017). Saravanajayam et al. (2015) reported seropositivity of males at 33.33% (5/15) and seropositivity of females at 67.92% (163/240).
Lotfi et al. 2016 reported the seropositivity of females at 5.5% (28/513). Across different studies in the world, females have higher seropositivity compared to male buffaloes. This is because females have been exposed more to artificial insemination and gynecological examinations. Other than that, physiological and environmental stress, such as during pregnancy and lactation, Stress can compromise the immune system, making them more susceptible to infection.
Breed wise prevalence
In the present study, Nili-ravi breed buffaloes showed higher seropositivity of 57.39% [60.22(52.79-67.37)], Murrah breed buffaloes showed seropositivity of 20.85% [18.22(16.42-20.12)] and non-descript buffaloes showed 13.76% [10.07(8.22-12.13)] seropositivity, the statistical analysis found to be significant (χ2= 238.59, p=<0.0001) (Table 2).
Romero-Salas et al. (2018) reported 58.93% (122/207) seropositivity in Murrah, which belongs to Veracruz, Mexico. In 2015, a study showed 54.34% (18/34) and 51.85% (14/27) seropositivity in Murrah breed and non-descript, respectively
(Saravanajayam et al., 2015). In 2015, a study on an organized dairy farm reported 69.18% (92/133) seropositivity in Murrah
(Krishnamoorthy et al. 2015).
Patil et al. (2023b) reported 44.08% (320/726), 37.50 (3/8) and 41.24% (73/177) seropositivity in Murrah, Nili-ravi and non-descript, respectively.
Saravanajayam et al. (2017) reported seropositivity of 22.22% and 17.28% in Murrah and non-descript, respectively.
Selvaraj et al. (2008) reported 8.56% (16/187) seropositivity belongs to 179 nondescript and 8 Murrah-graded buffaloes.
Batool et al. (2022) reported a seropositivity of 51.5% (103/200) in the Nili-Ravi bred, which belongs to Pakistan.